In this article Jump to a section
The main difference between reflux and colic is timing. Reflux is linked to feeds: your baby brings up milk, coughs, gulps or gets upset during or shortly after feeding. Colic is crying that has no clear cause, often in long spells in the late afternoon and evening, in a baby who is otherwise well and feeding normally.
If you are reading this with a crying baby on your shoulder, you are not alone and you are not doing anything wrong. Reflux and colic look very alike from the outside. Both bring lots of crying, an arched back, clenched fists and a parent who has tried everything. This guide walks you through the clues that tell them apart, what helps each one, and when to get your baby checked.
If your baby feeds, seems settled on your shoulder and then screams the moment you lay them flat, that pattern points more towards reflux than colic. This ex-midwife's guide to reflux and the baby who cannot be put down explains why that happens and what can help.
What is reflux in babies?
Reflux is when milk comes back up from your baby's tummy into their food pipe, and sometimes out of their mouth. The NHS says reflux is when a baby brings up milk, or is sick, during or shortly after feeding. It is very common and usually gets better on its own.
It happens because the muscle at the top of a baby's tummy is still developing, so milk can slip back up more easily. The NHS says reflux usually starts before 8 weeks old and gets better by the time a baby is 1.
Common signs of reflux include:
- Bringing up milk or being sick during or shortly after feeds
- Coughing or hiccupping while feeding
- Being unsettled during feeds, pulling off the breast or bottle
- Swallowing or gulping after burping or feeding
- Crying and not settling, especially when laid flat
- Not gaining weight, if they are not keeping enough milk down
Some babies have the signs of reflux without bringing any milk up. This is called silent reflux, and it can be harder to spot. Our guide to silent reflux in babies covers it in detail.
What is colic?
Colic is when a healthy baby cries a lot and there is no obvious cause. The NHS says colic may be the reason if your baby cries for more than 3 hours a day, 3 days a week, for at least 1 week, and is otherwise healthy.
Colic can start when a baby is a few weeks old and usually stops by 3 to 4 months. HealthyChildren.org, the parent website of the American Academy of Paediatrics, says about one in five babies develop colic, usually between the second and fourth weeks. It says crying usually peaks at about 3 hours a day by 6 weeks, then drops to 1 or 2 hours a day by 3 to 4 months.
During a colic episode, the NHS says your baby may:
- Be very hard to soothe or settle
- Clench their fists
- Go red in the face
- Bring their knees up to their tummy or arch their back
- Have a rumbly tummy or be very windy
Nobody knows exactly what causes colic. It may be linked to digestion, a growing nervous system that finds it hard to calm down, or in some babies a food allergy such as cows' milk allergy. Colic is not caused by anything you did.
Reflux vs colic: the key differences
Because the symptoms overlap so much, it helps to look at patterns rather than single moments. Ask yourself these questions.
When does the crying happen?
Reflux: crying is usually tied to feeds. It often starts during a feed or within a short time afterwards, and it can happen at any time of day or night.
Colic: crying often comes in long spells, very often in the afternoon and evening, and is not clearly linked to feeds. Many parents notice it happens at around the same time every day. If evenings are your hardest time, our guide to the witching hour may help too.
Is milk coming back up?
Reflux: often yes. Spit-up, sicky burps, coughing and gulping are common. With silent reflux you may notice swallowing, sour breath or a hoarse cry instead.
Colic: usually not. Babies with colic may spit up a little like any baby, but bringing up milk is not the main feature.
How does your baby feed?
Reflux: feeds can be a struggle. Your baby may pull away, arch, cough, cry and come back, seem hungry but upset, or take lots of small feeds.
Colic: feeding is usually normal. Your baby feeds well and gains weight, then has crying spells that seem to come from nowhere.
Does position make a difference?
Reflux: many babies are calmer when held upright and more upset when laid flat, especially straight after a feed.
Colic: position may not change much. Some colicky babies like being held over a shoulder or across your lap, but the crying often carries on whatever you do.
How old is your baby?
Reflux: usually starts before 8 weeks and gets better by around 1 year.
Colic: usually starts in the first few weeks and eases by 3 to 4 months.
Reflux vs colic at a glance
- Link to feeds: reflux, strong. Colic, weak or none.
- Time of day: reflux, any time, often after feeds. Colic, often afternoon and evening.
- Bringing up milk: reflux, common (unless silent reflux). Colic, not a main sign.
- Coughing, gulping or hiccups during feeds: common with reflux, less so with colic.
- Calmer upright: often with reflux. Not much difference with colic.
- Usual start: reflux, before 8 weeks. Colic, a few weeks old.
- Usually better by: reflux, around 1 year. Colic, 3 to 4 months.
Can a baby have both reflux and colic?
Yes. Some babies have reflux and also have long crying spells in the evening. The two can overlap, and a baby who is uncomfortable after feeds may also be harder to settle later in the day. You do not have to label it perfectly. What matters is noticing the patterns, trying the gentle things that help, and getting your baby checked if you are worried.
A simple feed and crying diary for a few days can make this much clearer. Jot down when your baby fed, how long they cried, whether milk came up and what seemed to help. It is also really useful to show your health visitor or GP.
What helps a baby with reflux
The NHS says your baby does not usually need to see a doctor for reflux, as long as they are happy, healthy and gaining weight. These are the steps the NHS suggests:
- Hold your baby upright during feeds. Keep their head higher than their tummy.
- Keep them upright for as long as possible after feeds. This gives milk time to settle before your baby is laid down.
- Burp them regularly during feeds, not just at the end. Our guide on how to burp a baby shows three positions to try.
- Ask for help with feeding. A health visitor can check breastfeeding position or bottle feeding technique.
- Always lay your baby flat on their back to sleep. Not on their side or front.
- Do not raise the head of the cot or Moses basket. The NHS is clear on this.
If reflux is worse at night, our guide to helping a baby with reflux sleep at night has more ideas that follow safe sleep advice.
What helps a baby with colic
There is no quick fix for colic, but there are things that can make the crying spells easier for both of you. The NHS suggests:
- Holding or cuddling your baby when they are crying a lot
- Holding them upright during feeds and winding them after feeds
- Gently rocking them over your shoulder, in their Moses basket or in a pram
- A warm bath, which calms some babies quickly
- Gentle white noise, like a radio or fan in the background
- Carrying on feeding as usual. If you are breastfeeding, you do not need to change your diet unless a doctor suggests it.
HealthyChildren.org also suggests walking with your baby in a carrier, gentle baby massage, and laying your baby tummy down across your knees while you rub their back. That last one is for when you are holding them and they are awake. If they fall asleep, lay them on their back in their cot.
The NHS says anti-colic drops, herbal remedies and probiotic supplements are not recommended because there is no evidence they help. It also advises against spinal manipulation and cranial osteopathy. Our full guide to soothing a colicky baby has a step by step plan for the hardest evenings.
A gentle helper for the after-feed stretch
If your baby's crying is worst when you lay them down after a feed, the hard part of your day is often that long upright stretch with no free hands. CradlePod™ is a contoured lounger that keeps your baby comfortably supported and gently inclined during feeds, after feeds and supervised awake time. It is designed for babies with reflux and colic, and it gives you a comfortable place to rest your baby right next to you, so you can have your arms back for a few minutes. Trusted by 30,000+ parents, with 1,000+ reviews and a 30-day guarantee. CradlePod is for supervised awake time only, never for sleep. When your baby drifts off, move them to their cot, flat on their back.
Is it reflux, colic or something else?
Lots of crying has simpler causes. Before you settle on reflux or colic, the NHS suggests checking whether your baby is:
- Hungry, or needs a longer or calmer feed
- In need of a nappy change
- Windy and needing a burp
- Constipated
- Tired or overstimulated
- Too hot or too cold
Some babies also have a cows' milk allergy, which can look like reflux or colic. The NHS says your GP may check for this. Our guide on why babies cry walks through the other common reasons, and our post on baby crying after feeding covers after-feed crying in more depth.
Common mistakes when telling reflux and colic apart
Judging from one bad day. Every baby has rough days. Look at the pattern over several days before deciding what is going on.
Assuming all spit-up is reflux that needs a doctor. Bringing up some milk is very common. If your baby is happy and gaining weight, it is usually normal. Our guide to baby reflux symptoms helps you tell normal spit-up from something more.
Changing feeds or formula without advice. Switching milks or cutting foods from your diet can be confusing and is not always needed. Talk to your health visitor or GP first.
Raising the cot or using sleep positioners. It is tempting, but the NHS advice is to keep your baby flat on their back for sleep, with the cot flat.
Trying a new trick every ten minutes. Rapid changes can overstimulate a crying baby. Pick one or two calm things and give them a fair go.
Thinking it is your fault. Reflux and colic are not caused by bad parenting. They are common, and they pass.
Looking after yourself through the crying
Hours of crying are hard on any parent. The NHS says that feeling so tired and angry you cannot take any more happens to a lot of parents, and you should not be ashamed to ask for help.
If you feel you are reaching your limit, put your baby down somewhere safe, like their cot, and step into another room for a few minutes to calm down. Then go back. No matter how frustrated you feel, never shake a baby. If you can, share the evenings with a partner, friend or family member, even for an hour. Cry-sis offers free support on 0800 448 0737, 9am to 10pm, every day. Our guide to postpartum exhaustion may also help.
When to speak to your GP or health visitor
See your GP or call NHS 111 if:
- Your baby is not gaining weight, or is losing weight
- Reflux starts for the first time after 6 months, or is still there after age 1
- Colic symptoms are still there after 4 months
- Nothing seems to be helping, or you are finding it hard to cope
- You are worried about how much your baby is crying
Ask for an urgent GP appointment or call NHS 111 if your baby vomits green or yellow fluid or blood, is sick with a lot of force, has blood in their poo, has a swollen or tender tummy, has a very high temperature, keeps being sick and cannot keep fluids down, has signs of dehydration, refuses to feed, or will not stop crying and seems very distressed.
Go to A&E or call 999 if your baby has a weak or high-pitched cry, or a cry that does not sound like them, or if they are struggling to breathe, floppy or hard to wake. Trust your instincts. You know your baby best.
Whether it turns out to be reflux, colic or a bit of both, most babies come through it with time, upright cuddles and a lot of patience. If your baby is happiest upright after feeds and your arms need a break, CradlePod™ gives you a comfortable, inclined place to rest them during supervised awake time, and every order comes with the free Calm Baby Guide and a free LullaCloth.
Free download: the Calm Baby Guide
We built a free 14-page guide for parents working through baby sleep gently. 5 real-parent sleep hacks that do not involve crying-it-out, plus practical techniques you can use tonight. Plain language, no fluff. You can download the Calm Baby Guide here, no purchase required.
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if my baby has reflux or colic?
Look at when the crying happens. Reflux crying is usually linked to feeds and often comes with spit-up, coughing or gulping. Colic crying comes in long spells, often in the evening, in a baby who feeds normally. A diary over a few days makes the pattern easier to see.
Can reflux be mistaken for colic?
Yes, very easily. Both cause crying, arching and clenched fists. Silent reflux is especially easy to mistake for colic because no milk comes up. If crying is closely tied to feeds or lying flat, mention reflux to your GP or health visitor.
Does colic happen after every feed?
Usually not. Colic tends to come in spells at around the same time each day, often the late afternoon or evening, rather than after every feed. Crying after most feeds is more likely to be wind, reflux or a feeding issue.
What age do reflux and colic stop?
The NHS says colic usually stops by 3 to 4 months, and reflux usually gets better by the time a baby is 1. See your GP if colic carries on past 4 months or reflux carries on past 1.
Is arching the back a sign of reflux or colic?
It can be either. Arching during or just after feeds points more towards reflux. Arching during long crying spells with knees pulled up and a red face is common with colic and wind.
Do babies with reflux cry more when lying down?
Many do, especially straight after a feed. That is why the NHS suggests keeping your baby upright for as long as possible after feeds. For sleep, always lay them flat on their back and do not raise the cot.
Can a change of formula help reflux or colic?
Sometimes, but only with advice. The NHS says a GP may suggest thickened formula for some formula-fed babies with reflux, or check for cows' milk allergy. Do not switch formulas or cut foods from your diet without speaking to your GP or health visitor first.
The bottom line
Reflux and colic both bring a lot of crying, but the pattern gives them away. Reflux is linked to feeds, spit-up and lying flat. Colic is long spells of crying with no clear cause, often in the evening, in a baby who is feeding well.
For reflux, focus on upright feeds, regular burping and calm upright time afterwards, with flat, back sleeping in a clear cot. For colic, focus on holding, rocking, gentle noise and getting support for yourself. For both, keep a short diary and speak to your health visitor or GP if you are worried.
This stage is hard, and it does pass. You are already doing the most important thing: paying close attention to your baby.